Health Watch
“The following is an opinion piece by Dr Richard Stiles. It was published in the Lithgow Mercury on 1/5/12. Dr Stiles works as a medical practitioner in Lithgow. His medical work has led him to a concerned awareness of the burden of disease and premature mortality that the Lithgow region shares with other coal communities in Australia and around the world. A variety of health studies point toward the environmental impacts of coal mining and burning, and how these interface with human health issues. However it is an area that is generally under-studied, especially given the magnitude of the health problems that are shared by these communities. Mining and power generation companies have not undertaken detailed studies of the health impacts of their industries. In the absence of these, it will be important for public health authorities to more comprehensively analyse the nexus between coal and human health – especially as these relate to local mining communities.“
Living Coal
As the sun comes up, we turn on our kettles to make the brews that open our eyes to the new day. Back in the power stations the confluence of these little actions requires a major burst of electricity to go out into the grid. The coal furnaces are opened up – 10 million cuppas go up the stacks.
What’s it like to live in a coal community?
Coal communities are often proud of their heritage, of the hard work that has made that heritage. There remains a solidarity and community feeling within these communities that is fast disappearing in the cities, where most of us now live. They can also feel defensive, as the role of coal in our world has become more challenged.
I work as a doctor in Lithgow, one of these coal communities – and I have come to see another side, another cost, of our modern power needs: illness and death.
Lithgow shares a health profile like many of the coal communities: high asthma rates (especially children), higher levels of diabetes, heart attacks, strokes and cancers, and more premature deaths. The political apparatus tries to push these off on to people’s adverse lifestyle choices – too many Big Macs and ciggies, not enough exercise. It’s always easier to blame people for their bad choices.
But why do coal communities have worse health figures than other communities with similar lifestyle profiles? Surely it couldn’t be their environments, with their local industries that mine and burn your morning cuppa?
Illness and death for jobs is the unspoken rationale. If people can earn money digging up and burning coal, then they can accept dying a bit earlier. That’s fair enough, isn’t it?
William Castleden et al, in the Sept. 2011 Medical Journal of Australia, have outlined, "The mining and burning of coal: effects on health and the environment".It is stark reading. Mining and transport accidents, adverse local health profiles – of both body and mind, local and global environmental costs (global warming not the least) – these are the tailings of our cups of coffee, at least currently while 84% of them are made from coal-generated power in this country. The authors hold that if the full social, health and environmental costs of coal are included, it is far from a cheap energy source.
Why do we keep mining and burning coal? Clearly it’s about money - for governments and mining companies (with a diminutive trickle to local communities) - and about ‘cheap’ power – cheap because the costs are carried by less fortunate others.
We have some new initiatives in our region. The mining companies, Coalpac Pty Ltd and Enhance Place Pty Ltd, are seeking to significantly expand their open cut mining operations via the Coalpac Consolidation Project and the Pine Dale Stage 2 extension, respectively.
Consider the residents of Cullen Bullen and Blackmans Flat. If Coalpac Pty Ltd gets its way, Cullen Bullen will be almost completely ringed by open cut mines. While residents sip their morning cuppas, they will also be hearing and feeling mining blasts that shake their dwellings, and breathing in dust clouds that filter into their homes.
If Enhance Place Pty Ltd succeeds, Blackmans Flat residents will need to contend with an industrial assault on their local landscape – levelling pagoda-filled hills, razing the biodiverse forest that unfortunately sits over the coal. They already live under the shadow of the Mt Piper coal-fired power station, with its pollution and overflowing fly ash dam.
Even the mining orientated Lithgow City Council has voted against Coalpac’s proposal. They too are aware that these new open cut mines represent a significant increase in impact when compared to the traditional underground mines of the region.
Only 2 of the last 1000 or so mine applications have been rejected by the NSW government - one because the mines had the gumption to suggest mining out the horse studs of the rich and famous, the other because of overwhelming social and environmental costs.
We have so many reasons to move away from coal - or else, ultimately, it will not just be those poor bastards in Cullen Bullen and Blackmans Flat who will be the unfortunates. It will be all of us. How much effort is it worth to us, to try to extricate ourselves from this sooty mess?
I hope these mines won’t go ahead. I hope these towns will retain the rich natural heritage of their hinterlands. I hope the locals can partner with industry and use their region’s assets in other ways. We all deserve the right to live in a healthy community.
This is a microcosm of the shift – in thinking and in living – that we all need to contemplate.
Enjoy your cuppa!
Dr Richard Stiles
Medical practitioner, with an interest in moral philosophy and human sustainability
What’s it like to live in a coal community?
Coal communities are often proud of their heritage, of the hard work that has made that heritage. There remains a solidarity and community feeling within these communities that is fast disappearing in the cities, where most of us now live. They can also feel defensive, as the role of coal in our world has become more challenged.
I work as a doctor in Lithgow, one of these coal communities – and I have come to see another side, another cost, of our modern power needs: illness and death.
Lithgow shares a health profile like many of the coal communities: high asthma rates (especially children), higher levels of diabetes, heart attacks, strokes and cancers, and more premature deaths. The political apparatus tries to push these off on to people’s adverse lifestyle choices – too many Big Macs and ciggies, not enough exercise. It’s always easier to blame people for their bad choices.
But why do coal communities have worse health figures than other communities with similar lifestyle profiles? Surely it couldn’t be their environments, with their local industries that mine and burn your morning cuppa?
Illness and death for jobs is the unspoken rationale. If people can earn money digging up and burning coal, then they can accept dying a bit earlier. That’s fair enough, isn’t it?
William Castleden et al, in the Sept. 2011 Medical Journal of Australia, have outlined, "The mining and burning of coal: effects on health and the environment".It is stark reading. Mining and transport accidents, adverse local health profiles – of both body and mind, local and global environmental costs (global warming not the least) – these are the tailings of our cups of coffee, at least currently while 84% of them are made from coal-generated power in this country. The authors hold that if the full social, health and environmental costs of coal are included, it is far from a cheap energy source.
Why do we keep mining and burning coal? Clearly it’s about money - for governments and mining companies (with a diminutive trickle to local communities) - and about ‘cheap’ power – cheap because the costs are carried by less fortunate others.
We have some new initiatives in our region. The mining companies, Coalpac Pty Ltd and Enhance Place Pty Ltd, are seeking to significantly expand their open cut mining operations via the Coalpac Consolidation Project and the Pine Dale Stage 2 extension, respectively.
Consider the residents of Cullen Bullen and Blackmans Flat. If Coalpac Pty Ltd gets its way, Cullen Bullen will be almost completely ringed by open cut mines. While residents sip their morning cuppas, they will also be hearing and feeling mining blasts that shake their dwellings, and breathing in dust clouds that filter into their homes.
If Enhance Place Pty Ltd succeeds, Blackmans Flat residents will need to contend with an industrial assault on their local landscape – levelling pagoda-filled hills, razing the biodiverse forest that unfortunately sits over the coal. They already live under the shadow of the Mt Piper coal-fired power station, with its pollution and overflowing fly ash dam.
Even the mining orientated Lithgow City Council has voted against Coalpac’s proposal. They too are aware that these new open cut mines represent a significant increase in impact when compared to the traditional underground mines of the region.
Only 2 of the last 1000 or so mine applications have been rejected by the NSW government - one because the mines had the gumption to suggest mining out the horse studs of the rich and famous, the other because of overwhelming social and environmental costs.
We have so many reasons to move away from coal - or else, ultimately, it will not just be those poor bastards in Cullen Bullen and Blackmans Flat who will be the unfortunates. It will be all of us. How much effort is it worth to us, to try to extricate ourselves from this sooty mess?
I hope these mines won’t go ahead. I hope these towns will retain the rich natural heritage of their hinterlands. I hope the locals can partner with industry and use their region’s assets in other ways. We all deserve the right to live in a healthy community.
This is a microcosm of the shift – in thinking and in living – that we all need to contemplate.
Enjoy your cuppa!
Dr Richard Stiles
Medical practitioner, with an interest in moral philosophy and human sustainability
Tuesday 7th August 2012
MEDIA RELEASE: For immediate release
MEDIA RELEASE: For immediate release
NSW Health raises concerns over Coalpac Pty Ltd's proposal
Residents and environment groups have had their concerns around potential health threats from the Coalpac Consolidation Project, echoed by NSW Health. In its submission on the proposal, the agency identifies a number of long-term health effects from dust, emissions from blasting and noise effects for the people of Cullen Bullen and the local school.
Regarding air quality issues due to mining activities, the agency's submission states:
We have a number of concerns, particularly in relation to the long-term health effects from dust, emissions from blasting and noise effects.
...there is growing evidence that populations subject to elevated levels of course particulate matter conditions from mines have an increased risk of adverse health outcomes, particularly on the respiratory system.
... there is no evidence or explanation within the proposal of how (Coalpac will) conduct their operations if elevated dust levels are recorded and environmental conditions are unstable."The Blue Mountains Conservation Society has worked closely with residents from the Cullen Bullen community who had concerns and questions around this proposal,"says Justin McKee, Blue Mountains Conservation Society.
"The most commonly perceived threat were around threats to health, the kids attending Cullen Bullen Primary School and the livelihoods of residents."
Residents' concerns were tabled with the legislative assembly in a petition tabled by the Local Member for Bathurst, Paul Toole in May 2012.
"In a public meeting this year, Coalpac delivered the same answer to questions from resident's regarding air quality, dust and noise. The company touted its undeveloped, unplanned and untested 'real time monitoring system' would save the day. We thoroughly support comments from the Nepean Blue Mountains Local Health District around this ludicrous notion:
that the proposed "real-time management system" reduce peak particulate matter emissions will have no impact on reducing the overall increase in long-term exposure to particulate matter for local residents."Coalpac is in no position to communicate to local residents that their is no basis for their concerns around health or livelihood at this stage. NSW Health have identified legitimate points for concern," says Mr Justin McKee.
The Nepean Blue Mountains Local Health District made a several recommendations on 'Air quality issues due to blasting' and 'Noise and vibration' that include:
> That a detailed health risk assessment of the potential impacts of blasting on Cullen Bullen is undertaken; and > That noise blasting impacts on occupied houses and Cullen Bullen Primary School are reduced as far as feasible. "Disturbing the environment to the degree Coalpac wishes too comes at a cost. The cost here is environmental and human health. It is disappointing that Lithgow City Council sold the people of Cullen Bullen out on this proposal," concludes Mr McKee.
Link to EPA submission: http://bit.ly/P3vhbX
Media Contacts: Justin McKee 0404 824 020
Regarding air quality issues due to mining activities, the agency's submission states:
We have a number of concerns, particularly in relation to the long-term health effects from dust, emissions from blasting and noise effects.
...there is growing evidence that populations subject to elevated levels of course particulate matter conditions from mines have an increased risk of adverse health outcomes, particularly on the respiratory system.
... there is no evidence or explanation within the proposal of how (Coalpac will) conduct their operations if elevated dust levels are recorded and environmental conditions are unstable."The Blue Mountains Conservation Society has worked closely with residents from the Cullen Bullen community who had concerns and questions around this proposal,"says Justin McKee, Blue Mountains Conservation Society.
"The most commonly perceived threat were around threats to health, the kids attending Cullen Bullen Primary School and the livelihoods of residents."
Residents' concerns were tabled with the legislative assembly in a petition tabled by the Local Member for Bathurst, Paul Toole in May 2012.
"In a public meeting this year, Coalpac delivered the same answer to questions from resident's regarding air quality, dust and noise. The company touted its undeveloped, unplanned and untested 'real time monitoring system' would save the day. We thoroughly support comments from the Nepean Blue Mountains Local Health District around this ludicrous notion:
that the proposed "real-time management system" reduce peak particulate matter emissions will have no impact on reducing the overall increase in long-term exposure to particulate matter for local residents."Coalpac is in no position to communicate to local residents that their is no basis for their concerns around health or livelihood at this stage. NSW Health have identified legitimate points for concern," says Mr Justin McKee.
The Nepean Blue Mountains Local Health District made a several recommendations on 'Air quality issues due to blasting' and 'Noise and vibration' that include:
> That a detailed health risk assessment of the potential impacts of blasting on Cullen Bullen is undertaken; and > That noise blasting impacts on occupied houses and Cullen Bullen Primary School are reduced as far as feasible. "Disturbing the environment to the degree Coalpac wishes too comes at a cost. The cost here is environmental and human health. It is disappointing that Lithgow City Council sold the people of Cullen Bullen out on this proposal," concludes Mr McKee.
Link to EPA submission: http://bit.ly/P3vhbX
Media Contacts: Justin McKee 0404 824 020
Media Release 19.8.2013
Senate Committee recommends Health Impact Assessments
The Gunnedah Basin Health Impact Assessment Steering Committee has welcomed the findings of the recent Federal Senate inquiry into the Impacts on health of air quality in Australia. The parliamentary committee made a number of recommendations includingthat Health Impact Assessments (HIA) be required as part of the assessment process for all new coal developments.
“Our community has directly lobbied the NSW Planning Minister and Health Minister on the need for Health Impact Assessments in the planning process for large scale coal mines and coal seam gas proposals” said Phil Laird chairman of the steering committee.
“In particular to establish baseline levels of physical, mental, social and environmental health. Unfortunately our representations have not been included in Part 4A planning assessments”.
“Our committee undertook a structured stakeholder consultation and scoping process with the outcome being that proper assessments of community health and wellbeing are fundamental to our community’s expectations” he said.
“Proposed new planning amendments to use the ‘significance of the resource’ as the primary planning consideration clearly shows a disconnect between the approach of Planning NSW and the needs of the wider community”.
“We strongly encourage the state government to drop its proposed amendments and ensure that Health Impact Assessments are a key component in a revamped state significant planning process.”
For Comment: Phil Laird 0428 712622
Gunnedah Basin HIA proposal http://maulescreek.org/gunnedah-basin-health-impact-assessment/
“Our community has directly lobbied the NSW Planning Minister and Health Minister on the need for Health Impact Assessments in the planning process for large scale coal mines and coal seam gas proposals” said Phil Laird chairman of the steering committee.
“In particular to establish baseline levels of physical, mental, social and environmental health. Unfortunately our representations have not been included in Part 4A planning assessments”.
“Our committee undertook a structured stakeholder consultation and scoping process with the outcome being that proper assessments of community health and wellbeing are fundamental to our community’s expectations” he said.
“Proposed new planning amendments to use the ‘significance of the resource’ as the primary planning consideration clearly shows a disconnect between the approach of Planning NSW and the needs of the wider community”.
“We strongly encourage the state government to drop its proposed amendments and ensure that Health Impact Assessments are a key component in a revamped state significant planning process.”
For Comment: Phil Laird 0428 712622
Gunnedah Basin HIA proposal http://maulescreek.org/gunnedah-basin-health-impact-assessment/
